Best Income Protection Insurance NZ: Ranked by Claims Paid
QuoteHub ranks the best income protection insurance in New Zealand as the policy from the insurer with the strongest published claims record, not the cheapest quote. Ranked on the payout rates each insurer publishes itself, Asteron Life leads for the year to 30 June 2024, ahead of Partners Life to 31 March 2025, Fidelity Life to 30 June 2025 and AIA for calendar 2025. Reporting periods differ, so the four are not like-for-like.
In short
- Asteron Life paid 97% of the Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims it received in the year to 30 June 2024 (Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024).
- Partners Life paid 95% of all assessed claims in the year to 31 March 2025, including $60.7 million of income cover claims (This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure).
- Fidelity Life paid 93% of all claims received in the year to 30 June 2025 (customer brochure) and AIA paid 91% in calendar 2025 (RiskinfoNZ, 12 May 2026), on denominators that are not directly comparable.
The best income protection insurance in NZ is best judged on the one number that decides whether the policy ever works for you: the share of claims the insurer actually paid. Asteron Life leads at 97% of Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims received in the year to 30 June 2024 (Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024). Partners Life paid 95% of all assessed claims in the year to 31 March 2025 (This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure). Fidelity Life paid 93% of all claims received in the year to 30 June 2025 (Claims we have paid customer brochure). AIA paid 91% of all claims received in calendar 2025 (Claims Compass 2025, reported by RiskinfoNZ, 12 May 2026). The periods and denominators differ, so the four are not like-for-like.
Price is the wrong first question, because every one of these insurers will quote you a different number for the same profile and none of those numbers tells you whether a claim gets paid. Definitions, benefit periods and published claims behaviour do. That is the order this ranking uses.
Want the matrix rather than the verdict? Our income protection insurance comparison sets all six insurers side by side on waiting periods, benefit periods, agreed value, offsets and the own occupation test. This page answers the narrower question of which cover to choose, and why.
Your ability to earn is almost certainly your largest financial asset, and ACC does not protect it against illness. Income protection is the only product that does, which is why many New Zealand advisers rank it ahead of life insurance and health insurance when a budget only stretches to one.
How We Selected Our Top Picks
Five criteria, weighted by how much each one matters at the point of claim, and each assessed only against data the insurer or a named public source has published.
- Claims performance, 30%. The share of claims the insurer actually pays, as it publishes the figure itself. An insurer that declines more claims is worth less, whatever the premium says.
- Product flexibility, 25%. Waiting periods, benefit periods, the agreed value or indemnity choice, partial disability terms and rehabilitation support.
- Premium competitiveness, 20%. Price against the cover provided, including how the insurer treats manual occupations.
- Financial strength, 15%. The ability to keep paying claims for decades, as graded by an approved rating agency.
- Claims support, 10%. Rehabilitation spend, non-financial support and any independent review route for a declined claim.
Every claims figure below carries the insurer, the exact period and a link. Reporting periods and denominators differ between insurers, so the percentages are not like-for-like, and we say so each time.
The Best Income Cover in NZ, Ranked
Four New Zealand insurers make our 2026 best income cover ranking. Partners Life is best overall, having paid 95% of all assessed claims in the year to 31 March 2025 (Partners Life, This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, retrieved 18 August 2026). Asteron Life has the best claims record, paying 97% of the Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims it received between 1 July 2023 and 30 June 2024 (Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024). AIA New Zealand is best for bundling across a single product ecosystem, and Fidelity Life is best for New Zealand ownership.
Best Overall: Partners Life
Partners Life accepted 95% of all assessed claims and paid $60.7 million of income cover claims in the year to 31 March 2025, both taken from its own This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, retrieved 18 August 2026. The acceptance rate covers every claim type, not income cover alone.
| Partners Life | Figure | Source and period |
|---|---|---|
| Claims accepted | 95% of all assessed claims | This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026 |
| Income cover claims paid | $60.7 million | This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, same period |
| Financial strength | A.M. Best A- (Excellent) | Partners Life news release, retrieved 8 September 2026. No more recent grade was readable on the Partners Life site that day; the Reserve Bank register carries the current rating for every licensed insurer |
Partners Life earns the top position on published claims behaviour, product depth and transparency. It paid 95% of all assessed claims and more than $325 million in total claims in the year to 31 March 2025 (Partners Life, This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, retrieved 18 August 2026), which provides confidence that valid claims are consistently honoured.
The product is fully configurable: waiting periods from 4 to 13 weeks, benefit periods from 2 years to age 65 or 70, agreed value and indemnity options, and a partial disability benefit for a gradual return to work. Its Customer Outcomes Review Committee gives a declined claim an independent review route, which few competitors publish.
Partners Life reports income cover claims across a wide range of health events, not accidents alone. That is the practical proof the product reaches beyond the accident-only scope of ACC.
Best for: Families seeking the strongest combination of claims reliability, product depth, and governance transparency. Self-employed Kiwis who need robust illness protection. Anyone who values knowing their insurer has a clear track record of paying claims.
Best Claims Record: Asteron Life
Asteron Life accepted 97% of the Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims it received between 1 July 2023 and 30 June 2024, and paid $112 million in total, of which $24.4 million was monthly income protection (Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024, retrieved 8 September 2026). That is the most recent year Asteron has published itself.
| Asteron Life | Figure | Source and period |
|---|---|---|
| Claims accepted | 97% of Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims received | Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024, 1 July 2023 to 30 June 2024, retrieved 8 September 2026 |
| Total claims paid | $112 million, of which $24.4 million was monthly income protection | Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024, year to 30 June 2024 |
| Financial strength | Fitch A+ (Strong) | Asteron Life, financial strength, retrieved 8 September 2026. The Reserve Bank register carries the rating for every licensed insurer |
Asteron Life paid out on 97% of the Trauma, Life and Income Protection claims it received in the year to 30 June 2024, with more than 95% acceptance in each of those three categories (Asteron Life media release, 11 December 2024, retrieved 8 September 2026). That is the highest published payout rate among the four insurers here. We rank on that figure because it is the most recent one Asteron has published itself. Trade title RiskinfoNZ reported on 2 March 2026 that an Asteron claims graphic put acceptance at 97.7% overall and 95.61% for income protection in the year to June 2025, on $117.9 million of claims paid (RiskinfoNZ, 2 March 2026, retrieved 8 September 2026). Asteron has not published that year on its own media page, so we report it as a second-hand figure rather than ranking on it. Its Fitch A+ (Strong) rating, published on Asteron's own page and current on 8 September 2026, points the same way over a long holding period (Asteron Life).
Asteron also lets you convert stepped premiums to level premiums during the policy term without full re-underwriting. That suits anyone who needs a low starting price now and wants long-term cost certainty later.
The ANZIIF Life Insurance Company of the Year awards in 2021, 2023, and 2024 represent peer-recognised endorsement of operational quality.
Best for: Clients who prioritise claims certainty above all other factors. Those who want the flexibility to transition from stepped to level premiums over time. Families seeking the confidence of the highest published acceptance rate in the market.
Best for Bundling: AIA New Zealand
AIA New Zealand accepted 91% of all claims received in calendar 2025 and paid $790 million in total, including $108.69 million of income protection (AIA Claims Compass 2025, reported by RiskinfoNZ, 12 May 2026, retrieved 18 August 2026). Both figures cover AIA's whole book, not income protection alone.
| AIA New Zealand | Figure | Source and period |
|---|---|---|
| Claims accepted | 91% of all claims received | AIA Claims Compass 2025, reported by RiskinfoNZ, 12 May 2026, calendar 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026 |
| Total claims paid | $790 million, including $108.69 million of income protection | AIA Claims Compass 2025, reported by RiskinfoNZ, 12 May 2026, calendar 2025 |
| Financial strength | Fitch AA (Very Strong) | AIA, Our Financial Strength Rating, retrieved 8 September 2026 |
AIA's income protection product sits within the broadest and most integrated product ecosystem in the NZ market. AIA applies a multi-policy discount when life cover, trauma, TPD insurance and health insurance are held together. The size of that discount depends on the mix and is confirmed at quote. Ask your adviser to price the bundle against the standalone alternatives.
The AIA Vitality programme is the other differentiator. Policyholders earn premium discounts by logging health and wellness activity, which turns proactive health management into a lower price. No other New Zealand insurer runs an equivalent programme at that scale.
AIA New Zealand Limited holds a Fitch AA (Very Strong) insurer financial strength rating (AIA, Our Financial Strength Rating, retrieved 8 September 2026), one grade below the top of the Fitch scale, which reflects the global group's scale behind the New Zealand entity. The $790 million paid in claims to more than 789,000 New Zealanders during 2025 (AIA NZ Claims Compass 2025, reported by riskinfonz, 12 May 2026) demonstrates the sheer volume of claims the company processes, providing confidence in operational capability.
Best for: Clients who want comprehensive multi-product cover with bundling discounts. Those who are motivated by wellness incentives to manage their health proactively. High-income earners who want the confidence of the highest-rated insurer in the market.
Best for NZ Ownership: Fidelity Life
Fidelity Life accepted 93% of all claims received between 1 July 2024 and 30 June 2025, paying $247.7 million in total and $47.5 million of income protection (Claims we have paid customer brochure, retrieved 18 August 2026). The percentage counts every claim type, so it is not an income protection acceptance rate on its own.
| Fidelity Life | Figure | Source and period |
|---|---|---|
| Claims accepted | 93% of all claims received | Claims we have paid customer brochure, 1 July 2024 to 30 June 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026 |
| Total claims paid | $247.7 million, including $47.5 million of income protection | Fidelity Life, Claims we have paid, same period |
| Financial strength | A.M. Best A- (Excellent) | Fidelity Life, Income protection cover factsheet, retrieved 8 September 2026 |
Fidelity Life is the largest NZ-owned life insurer, backed by NZ Super Fund and Ngāi Tahu Holdings. For Kiwis who value supporting locally owned businesses and want their premiums reinvested in the New Zealand economy, Fidelity Life is the clear choice.
The product carries the usual configuration options plus a milestone increase feature, which allows cover to rise at qualifying life events without new medical underwriting. It also spent $772,000 on rehabilitation support in FY2025 and helped 2,279 customers (RiskinfoNZ, 1 December 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026). That is money spent getting people back to work rather than only paying benefits.
Having paid more than $2 billion in claims in the 52 years since it was founded (riskinfonz, 1 December 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026), Fidelity Life has a deep operational track record that provides confidence alongside the NZ ownership credentials.
Best for: Clients who prioritise NZ ownership and local reinvestment. Growing families who benefit from milestone-based cover increases. Those transitioning from legacy Westpac Life policies who want a NZ-owned alternative.
What to Look for Regardless of Provider
Six things belong in any New Zealand income protection policy: an own occupation definition, a partial disability benefit, a mental health benefit you have read, agreed value cover if your income moves, a long enough benefit period, and inflation adjustment. Five years is a sensible minimum. A benefit to age 65 is the full answer.
Own occupation definition. If you are a specialist professional, ensure the policy defines inability to work as inability to perform your own specific occupation, not just any occupation.
A mental health benefit, checked explicitly. Mental health disorders accounted for 10% of Partners Life Income Cover claims assessed between 1 April 2024 and 31 March 2025, behind accident and injury at 42%, cancer at 15% and heart conditions at 11% (*This is Partners Life 2025* claims brochure, retrieved 18 August 2026). At that share it is not an edge case, and cover for it is not uniform across the market.
Partial disability benefit. Cancer treatment, surgery recovery, and mental health episodes often involve a gradual return to work. A partial disability benefit supplements your reduced earnings during this transition.
Agreed value (if relevant). If your income fluctuates - particularly relevant for the self-employed and commission earners - agreed value locks in the insured amount at application time, providing certainty at claim time.
Appropriate benefit period. A 2-year benefit period costs less but provides limited protection against long-term illness. A benefit to age 65 provides comprehensive protection. Five years is a sensible minimum for most working Kiwis.
Inflation adjustment. Some policies offer CPI-linked benefit increases. This ensures your income protection payout keeps pace with rising costs over the policy's lifetime.
What Drives Your Premium (2026)
Income protection premiums in New Zealand are driven by five variables: your age, your occupation class, the waiting period before the benefit starts, how long the benefit period runs, and your health and smoking status. Occupation class and waiting period are the two biggest levers a healthy applicant can actually control, and the same profile can be ranked from cheapest to dearest without quoting a price.
| Profile | Waiting Period | Benefit Period | Relative premium level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Office professional, $100K income, age 30 | 4 weeks | 2 years | Lowest - young, low-risk occupation, short benefit period |
| Office professional, $100K income, age 30 | 13 weeks | To age 65 | Low - the longer wait offsets much of the cost of cover to 65 |
| Office professional, $100K income, age 40 | 4 weeks | 5 years | Moderate - age is the main driver of the step up from 30 |
| Tradesperson, $100K income, age 35 | 4 weeks | 2 years | Moderate - a manual occupation class prices well above office work |
| Tradesperson, $100K income, age 35 | 13 weeks | To age 65 | Highest - manual occupation combined with the longest benefit period |
The variance between insurers pricing an identical profile can be wide, because each one weights occupation and health history in its own way. This reinforces the value of comparing across providers - the right insurer for your specific occupation and health profile may not be the right insurer for someone else.
Tax Considerations
The deduction and the tax on the benefit travel together. Inland Revenue lists "the cost of income protection insurance if the insurance payout would be taxable" as a claimable expense (Inland Revenue, non-business expenses, last updated 29 October 2025, retrieved 8 September 2026). It also states that an income protection payout replaces lost income and so "it's generally taxable" (Inland Revenue, insurance payouts, retrieved 8 September 2026). A policy built to pay a taxable benefit usually carries a deductible premium. One built to pay a tax-free benefit does not. Our income protection tax guide works through the employee, sole trader and company cases, and the self-employed section of our comparison covers the rest.
Which structure you are being quoted changes both the real cost of the premium and the net value of the benefit, so it is worth settling with your accountant before you compare two numbers.
Common Mistakes
Five mistakes recur. Buying on price without reading the definitions. Insuring too little. Relying on ACC. Never reviewing the cover as income rises. Choosing too short a benefit period. ACC covers accidents and pays nothing for illness, which is the exposure this product exists to answer.
Choosing the cheapest policy without comparing definitions. Price is important, but the policy definitions determine whether your claim is paid. A modest saving on annual premiums is meaningless if your claim is declined because the benefit definition is narrower than you expected.
Insuring too little. Many people insure 50% or 60% of their income to save on premiums. When a claim is made, the shortfall between the benefit and actual living costs can be significant. Insure to the maximum 75% where possible.
Relying on ACC. ACC covers injuries caused by accidents and does not cover illness at all (ACC, what we cover). A cancer diagnosis, a cardiac event or a serious mental health condition that stops you working attracts no ACC income replacement, and those are the events that keep people off work longest. Income protection is the only product that addresses that gap.
Not reviewing as income changes. A policy taken out on a $70,000 salary may be significantly inadequate if your income has risen to $120,000. Ensure your cover amount tracks your actual earnings, particularly if you hold an indemnity-based policy (which pays based on income at claim time).
Choosing too short a benefit period. A 2-year benefit period protects against short-term illness. The scenarios that ruin a household, such as extended cancer treatment, degenerative conditions and serious mental health episodes, last far longer. A 5-year or to-age-65 benefit period provides meaningful protection against these longer-tail risks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which insurer offers the best income cover in NZ?
Based on our analysis, Partners Life offers the best overall combination of claims payment (95% of assessed claims in the year to 31 March 2025), product flexibility, and governance transparency. However, Asteron Life leads on published payout rate at 97% for the year to 30 June 2024, and AIA offers the broadest bundling and wellness programme. The best insurer for you depends on your occupation, health profile, and what you prioritise most.
Does ACC cover me if I get sick and cannot work?
No. ACC covers injuries caused by accidents and does not cover illness at all (ACC, what we cover). If cancer, heart disease or a mental health condition stops you working, ACC pays nothing toward your income. Income protection insurance is the only product that replaces earnings in that situation, which is why advisers rank it ahead of most other personal cover.
How much does income protection insurance cost in NZ?
There is no standard price. Your premium is set by your age, occupation, waiting period, benefit period, and health, and the spread between the cheapest and dearest profile on the same income is wide. Office professionals generally pay materially less than manual workers for identical cover. Cross-reading two published New Zealand quote grids for the same five insurers, the same age and the same sex, a four-week waiting period on cover to age 65 was priced 51% to 113% above a 13-week wait, and the size of that gap depends heavily on which insurer you ask. The arithmetic sits in our income protection cost analysis. A licensed financial adviser can run a personalised quote across the insurers on our panel for your exact profile.
Can self-employed people claim income protection premiums as a tax deduction?
Inland Revenue lists "the cost of income protection insurance if the insurance payout would be taxable" as a claimable expense (Inland Revenue, non-business expenses, retrieved 8 September 2026). It also states that an income protection payout is generally taxable, because it replaces lost income (Inland Revenue, insurance payouts, retrieved 8 September 2026). Settle the structure with your accountant before you buy.
What is the difference between agreed value and indemnity income protection?
Agreed value locks in your insured income amount at the time you apply, so the insured amount is fixed regardless of later income changes. Indemnity bases the payout on your actual income at the time of claim, which means your benefit could be lower if your income has dropped. Agreed value costs slightly more but provides greater certainty, making it particularly valuable for self-employed people with fluctuating incomes.
References
- Partners Life, This is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure (claims assessed 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026)
- Partners Life, Financial Strength Rating Upgraded to 'A-' by AM Best (retrieved 8 September 2026)
- Asteron Life, Life Insurer of the Year reports 97% claims payout rate (11 December 2024, claims year to 30 June 2024, retrieved 8 September 2026)
- Asteron Life, financial strength (Fitch A+ (Strong), retrieved 8 September 2026)
- RiskinfoNZ, Asteron Life releases claims performance data (2 March 2026, year to June 2025, retrieved 8 September 2026)
- AIA New Zealand, Claims Compass 2025, reported by RiskinfoNZ (12 May 2026, calendar 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026)
- AIA New Zealand, Our Financial Strength Rating (Fitch AA (Very Strong), retrieved 8 September 2026)
- Fidelity Life, Claims we have paid customer brochure (1 July 2024 to 30 June 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026)
- Fidelity Life, Income protection cover factsheet (A.M. Best A- (Excellent), waiting and benefit period options, retrieved 8 September 2026)
- Fidelity Life claims result reported by RiskinfoNZ (1 December 2025, retrieved 18 August 2026)
- Reserve Bank of New Zealand, register of licensed insurers
- ACC, what we cover (retrieved 18 August 2026)
- Inland Revenue, non-business expenses (last updated 29 October 2025, retrieved 8 September 2026) and insurance payouts (retrieved 8 September 2026)
- Financial Markets Authority, insurance guidance
- Sorted.org.nz, income protection insurance
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute personalised financial advice. The top picks are our assessment against the published criteria above; they are not endorsements and may not be the best insurer for your situation. Every claims figure is reproduced from the named source beside it, scoped to the period stated, and reporting periods differ between insurers, so the rates are not like-for-like. Insurance is subject to underwriting, and terms, conditions, exclusions and stand-down periods apply. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). QuoteHub is a trading name. Henry Smith is a Financial Adviser (FSP1010699). The insurers on our advice panel are listed on our disclosure page.
Read the full insurance guides
Compare your cover with a licensed NZ adviser · free, no obligation.
Explore related pages: Life Insurance, Income Protection, Health Insurance, Trauma Insurance, Technology.