FMG pays $2.1 million after admitting pricing errors misled customers for years

Updated

Written by

Reviewed by Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver Licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931)

Our editorial process

Read this article with AI:

Photo for the story: FMG pays $2.1 million after admitting pricing errors misled customers for years

One error sat on 54,642 policies for 11 years, and 480 customers only found out when they made a claim.

FMG has admitted misleading its customers through two pricing errors that ran for more than a decade, and will pay $2.1 million, the Financial Markets Authority said on 9 February.

FMG Insurance Limited and Farmers' Mutual Group reported the problems themselves. The payment is an enforceable undertaking, a binding promise the regulator accepts instead of taking a company to court.

The FMA said the errors broke the fair dealing rule in the Financial Markets Conduct Act, which stops financial firms telling customers things that aren't true.

The first error hit 54,642 policies. Between 2013 and 2024 FMG applied a flat percentage to the yearly cover increase, when some policies promised an increase tied to inflation and others promised none.

For 480 customers the wrong cover amount only showed up when they claimed, and the claims had to be topped up. About 26,000 of the 54,642 are due refunds, worth about $3,380,000 in total.

In the second error, which ran from 2012 to 2024, 3,904 contents customers paid extra to name particular belongings on their policy. The ordinary contents cover already paid out on those items.

They are getting back about $1,936,000, an average of $496 each. Five claims were topped up, about $6,000 in all.

Refunds include GST and use of money interest, which compensates customers for the years FMG held money that wasn't its own.

By our sums, refunds and topped-up claims come to about $5,322,000, roughly two and a half times the $2.1 million FMG is paying the regulator.

Spread over the ten years the FMA counted, our sums put the yearly increase error at about $6 a customer a year. Nobody was going to spot that on a renewal notice.

Both customer counts start on 1 April 2014, the day the fair dealing rule came into force. That leaves up to two years of overcharging outside it, and the FMA release doesn't say whether that earlier money was repaid.

FMG describes itself as "100% owned by our rural members". A mutual has no outside shareholders, so the $2.1 million comes out of the members' shared funds.

The nearest comparison is IAG. The High Court fined it $19.5 million in October 2025 after about 269,000 customers were overcharged roughly $35 million across 41 problems, the FMA said.

IAG reported those problems between September 2021 and December 2024. FMG's two ran for 11 and 12 years.

Financial strength, published benefit limits and who underwrites which brand, side by side. Compare New Zealand insurers

This story is general information only. It isn't financial advice and doesn't take your circumstances, health or existing cover into account. Policy terms, conditions, exclusions and stand-down periods apply and can change. QuoteHub usually doesn't charge you for advice and may receive commission from insurers; our disclosure statement explains how we're paid.

Sources

Corrections · How we report the news

Wondering whether this affects your cover?

Book a cover review

Free, no obligation. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). Disclosure statement

Start your free comparison

Compare panel options first. A licensed NZ adviser can then review existing cover or help with an application.

Free, no obligation. Licensed NZ advisers · Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.