A bright, modern office lounge with glass walls and soft seating

Claims and insurer strength in New Zealand

How New Zealand insurers report claims, declined claim rates and financial strength, with every figure sourced and dated.

A grade belongs to the licensed entity that carries the risk. This report is not a recommendation. Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.

You read

Nothing: read the findings, then open any source

You see

Claims figures, strength grades and what each one does and does not tell you

Data

Insurer disclosures, rating agency grades and the Reserve Bank register, each linked

How to read this report

How New Zealand insurers report claims, declined claim rates and financial strength, with every figure sourced and dated.

  1. Read the summary findings.
  2. Compare the tables for the insurers you hold or are considering.
  3. Follow the source link, then ask a licensed adviser how it applies to you.

Five New Zealand life insurers publish a claims acceptance figure, between 91% and 97%, but each counts different claims over a different period, so the figures cannot honestly be ranked. A high past rate is not a promise about your claim: the policy wording, what you disclosed and the exclusions at the time decide it.

An insurance policy is a promise, and this report examines the two public measures of whether that promise gets kept: what each New Zealand insurer publishes about the claims it pays, and the financial strength rating behind each licensed insurer, including the insurers most New Zealanders have never heard of, because their policies are sold under better-known brand names. Every figure is transcribed from a named insurer, agency or regulator source with a link and a date; where an insurer publishes nothing, the gap is stated rather than estimated.

Published 18 August 2026 · claims sources re-checked 18 August 2026 · ratings verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026 · download the dataset (CSV)

Executive summary

QuoteHub’s evidence register covers 17 verified licensed NZ life and health insurers and the four direct-to-consumer brands they underwrite. Across that market, three findings stand out.

  1. Five insurers publish claims-outcome percentages, on four different bases, and the two largest health insurers publish none. AIA reports 92% of all claims received (2024), Asteron Life 97% of trauma, life and income protection claims received (2023–24), Partners Life 95% of all assessed claims (2024–25), Fidelity Life 93% of all new claims (2024–25) and Chubb Life 96% of claims paid (2024), but “received”, “assessed” and “new” claims are different denominators, the product scopes and twelve-month windows differ, and Chubb states no denominator at all. The league table these numbers invite cannot honestly be built, and Southern Cross, which itself states it pays over 71% of the value of all NZ health insurance claims, and nib publish no overall acceptance rate anywhere we could find.
  2. Some of New Zealand’s most advertised insurance brands are not insurers, and the ratings behind them span the widest part of the market’s range. NZ Seniors and OneChoice policies are both issued by Pinnacle Life Limited, rated B+ (Good) by A.M. Best, affirmed 15 April 2026, and Momentum Life holds a B (Fair) from A.M. Best, affirmed 11 February 2026. Seven of the eight insurers on QuoteHub’s advice panel hold an A-band grade from their agency; Momentum Life, which is on the panel through an online-application partnership, is the eighth. The pattern is not “direct equals weak”: AA Life is underwritten by Asteron Life (A+ (Strong), Fitch) and Southern Cross Life Insurance by Chubb Life (A (Excellent), A.M. Best). The finding is that the advertising never tells you which case you are in, the underwriter’s name and grade sit in the fine print, and grades from different agencies sit on different scales.
  3. The five insurers that publish dollar totals paid out more than $3.0 billion in claims in their most recent published years, and the real market total is higher. Southern Cross $1.498 billion (FY24), AIA $829.6 million (2024), Partners Life more than $325 million (2024–25), Fidelity Life $247.7 million (2024–25) and Asteron Life $112 million (2023–24) sum to $3.01 billion, but across five different twelve-month periods (ending June 2024, December 2024, March 2025 and June 2025, plus Southern Cross’s own FY24), so the figure is an indication of scale, not a market statistic. Chubb Life, nib and ten smaller licensed insurers publish no comparable totals on the pages captured, so the true annual figure is larger.

The honest counterweight: publishing any claims figure at all puts an insurer ahead of the market’s default silence. There is no standardised NZ disclosure format for claims outcomes, each insurer chooses its own measure, product scope and period, and every figure in this report is the insurer’s own published number, not an independent audit. A lower headline percentage on a wider denominator can reflect a more inclusive way of counting, not a less willing payer.

Who publishes claims outcomes, and what each number actually counts

New Zealand insurers are not required to publish claims acceptance statistics, so what exists is a patchwork of voluntary disclosures, each on its own terms. The table below is every claims-outcome statistic QuoteHub verified from a major NZ life or health insurer’s own published material for this edition, transcribed with its basis and period, plus the two major insurers whose absence from the list is itself the finding.

Every claims-outcome statistic published by a major NZ life or health insurer that QuoteHub verified for this edition, transcribed with its own basis and period. Each figure links to the insurer’s own source in its cell, with the retrieval date shown. The bases differ, these numbers must not be ranked against each other.

InsurerPublished claims outcome (linked source)PeriodWhat the number countsClaims paid in the period
AIA New ZealandQuoteHub review92% of all claims receivedAIA Claims Compass press release, retrieved 18 August 20261 Jan – 31 Dec 2024All claims received, across all products, the widest published denominator. The dollar total includes GST, maturities and surrenders ($103.7 million).$829.6 million
AIA New ZealandQuoteHub review91% of claimsAIA claims page, retrieved 18 August 20261 Jan – 31 Dec 2025Stated on AIA’s claims page as reported by its business Insights Team, a page figure, not a published report; includes GST, maturities and surrenders.$790.3 million
Asteron LifeQuoteHub review97% of trauma, life and income protection claims receivedAsteron Life media release, 11 December 2024, retrieved 18 August 20261 Jul 2023 – 30 Jun 2024Claims received in three product categories only (trauma, life, monthly income protection), with acceptance above 95% in each. The narrowest product scope and the oldest window of the published figures.$112 million
Partners LifeQuoteHub review95% of all assessed claimsThis is Partners Life 2025 claims brochure, retrieved 18 August 20261 Apr 2024 – 31 Mar 2025Assessed claims across all products, claims withdrawn before assessment sit outside this denominator, so it is not the same measure as “claims received”.more than $325 million
Fidelity LifeQuoteHub review93% of all new claimsFidelity Life, Claims we’ve paid, retrieved 15 August 20261 Jul 2024 – 30 Jun 2025New claims in the financial year (2,279 accepted). The dollar total spans all claims paid in the year, including continuing claims from earlier years.$247.7 million
Chubb Life NZQuoteHub review96% of claims paidChubb Life 2024 claims statistics, retrieved 18 August 2026calendar 2024Denominator not stated on the public page, the percentage cannot be compared precisely with any other insurer’s figure.No dollar total published on the pages captured.
Chubb Life NZQuoteHub review95% of claims paidChubb Life life insurance page, retrieved 18 August 2026calendar 2025Denominator not stated on the public page.No dollar total published on the pages captured.
Southern Cross Health SocietyQuoteHub reviewNo overall claims acceptance rate publishedSouthern Cross, About us, retrieved 18 August 2026FY24 (as published by Southern Cross)Publishes claims volume instead of an acceptance rate: the Society states it returned more than 93% of premium income to members as claims in FY24, and that it pays over 71% of the value of all NZ health insurance claims (its own statement, based on Financial Services Council data including an estimate for nib).$1.498 billion
nib nzQuoteHub reviewNo overall claims acceptance rate published on the pages capturednib claims page, retrieved 18 August 2026, nib publishes its claims process in detail but no overall acceptance percentage or annual claims-paid dollar total on the public pages captured, recorded as a gap, not a zero.No dollar total published on the pages captured.
Momentum LifeQuoteHub reviewNo claims acceptance rate or claims total published on the pages capturedMomentum Life financial strength page, with its Quick Life and Funeral policy wordings, retrieved 17 October 2026, Checked on Momentum Life’s own claims, FAQ and financial strength pages on 17 October 2026: no acceptance percentage and no annual dollar total. Its policy wordings state how fast it aims to pay once a claim is approved (usually within 24 to 48 hours for Funeral Insurance and within 48 hours for Quick Life), which is a payment-speed statement, not an acceptance rate. Recorded as a gap, not a zero.No dollar total published on the pages captured.

Why these numbers must not be ranked

Asteron’s 97% is the highest figure in the table; it is also the narrowest (three product categories) and the oldest (the year to June 2024). AIA’s 92% is the lowest of the life insurers’ percentages; it is also the widest, all claims received, across all products, on the largest claims book in the country. Partners counts assessed claims, which excludes claims withdrawn before assessment; Fidelity counts new claims in the year; Chubb publishes percentages without stating what they divide. Ordering those five numbers would assert a comparability the underlying measures do not have, which is why this report deliberately publishes no acceptance-rate chart or ranking, and why any article citing a single “best insurer for claims” from these figures is misreading them.

The other half of the finding is who is missing. Southern Cross, which states it pays over 71% of the value of all NZ health insurance claims (its own About page, based on Financial Services Council data including an estimate for nib, retrieved 18 August 2026), publishes claims volume and a premiums-returned ratio, but no acceptance rate. nib publishes its claims process in detail but no overall percentage on the pages captured (nib claims page, retrieved 18 August 2026). Health claims differ structurally from life claims, they are far more frequent, smaller, and often pre-approved before treatment, so a health acceptance rate would not mean the same thing as a life insurer’s figure. But no NZ health insurer currently gives consumers even that number, and declined claims are a real enough experience that QuoteHub keeps a dedicated guide to

what to do when a claim is declined

.

Why claims are not paid, and what an acceptance rate leaves out

An acceptance percentage counts the claims an insurer accepted. It does not say why the others were not paid, how long a claim took, how much was paid, or how many people never claimed because they expected to be refused. Whether a particular claim is paid is decided by the policy and the law, and four things recur.

  • Exclusions in the wording. Momentum Life’s Quick Life wording, for example, always excludes deaths from the effects of alcohol or drugs, war, terrorism, criminal activity and a list of dangerous jobs and pastimes (such as diving deeper than 40 metres or professional sport). Occupation and pastimes are not asked at application, so they matter at claim time.
  • Limits in the early years. Guaranteed acceptance cover trades health questions for a wait. On Quick Life, pre-existing conditions and suicide are excluded for the first 2 years; if a death from a pre-existing condition happens then and no claim is payable, the premiums are refunded. On Momentum Life’s Funeral Insurance, only an accidental death (within 90 days of the accident) is paid in the first 24 months, and any other death in that window gets the premiums back instead. These outcomes are written into the policy, and a headline acceptance rate does not show them.
  • What was said at application. Today a policyholder has to disclose matters an insurer might consider relevant. From 15 November 2027 (not yet in force) the Contracts of Insurance Act 2024 replaces that with a duty to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation, and the FMA says deliberate or reckless non-disclosure will have stronger consequences. On guaranteed acceptance cover there are no health questions to get wrong, but eligibility rules still apply: Momentum Life’s own site says Quick Life is not available to applicants diagnosed with a terminal illness or in palliative or hospice care.
  • Cover that was not in force. A policy that has lapsed for unpaid premiums, or a benefit that was never added, cannot pay.

If a claim is refused, the first step is the insurer’s own complaints process. Momentum Life’s wordings then point to the Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman (IFSO), a free service whose decision is binding on Momentum Life. Our guides to

what to do when a claim is declined

and to

how to claim on life insurance

set out the steps, and

Momentum Life’s complaints route

is covered on its own page.

The strength behind the promise: every verified rating

A claims statistic describes last year; a financial strength rating is an agency’s forward-looking opinion of an insurer’s ability to keep paying claims. New Zealand law requires licensed insurers to hold and disclose a rating from an approved agency (with limited exemptions), and the Reserve Bank of New Zealand’s register of licensed insurers records each insurer’s current grade. The table joins the two threads of this report: each verified licensed life and health insurer’s rating, and its published claims outcome where one exists.

Read the grades only against their own agency’s scale: A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s and Fitch use different ladders, and the same letter can sit at different heights on each, on A.M. Best’s scale, for example, A and A- are “Excellent”, B++ and B+ are “Good”, and B is “Fair”. The

Financial Strength Explorer

documents all three scales with sources; QuoteHub publishes no composite score and no cross-agency ranking.

Every verified licensed NZ life and health insurer, alphabetical by legal entity: financial strength rating (agency, linked source, effective date) joined with its published claims outcome where one exists. Ratings re-verified against the RBNZ register on

. Grades from different agencies use different scales and are not comparable; claims figures use different bases and are not comparable either.

Licensed insurerAlso underwritesAgencyRating (linked source)Effective datePublished claims outcome
AIA New Zealand Limitedtrades as AIA New ZealandQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewOwn brand onlyFitch RatingsAA (Very Strong)AIA NZ (own disclosure page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 202692% of all claims received, CY2024
American Income Life Insurance Companytrades as American Income LifeMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyA.M. BestAReserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Asteron Life Limitedtrades as Asteron LifeQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewAA LifeFitchA+Asteron Life (own disclosure page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 202697% of trauma, life and income protection claims received, Jul 2023 – Jun 2024
Chubb Life Insurance New Zealand Limitedtrades as Chubb Life NZQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewSouthern Cross Life InsuranceA.M. BestA (Excellent)Chubb NZ (own disclosure page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 202696% of claims paid, CY2024 (denominator not stated)
Co-operative Life Limitedtrades as Co-operative LifeMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyA.M. BestB++Reserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Fidelity Life Assurance Company Limitedtrades as Fidelity LifeQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewOwn brand onlyA.M. BestA- (Excellent)Fidelity Life (own disclosure page), verified 93% of all new claims, Jul 2024 – Jun 2025
Medical Life Assurance Society Limitedtrades as MAS (life)Market information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyStandard & Poor'sAReserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Medical Life Assurance Society Limitedtrades as MASMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyS&P Global RatingsAMAS (own financial strength page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Momentum Life Limited (FSP472286)trades as Momentum LifeQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureOwn brand onlyA.M. BestB (Fair), outlook stableMomentum Life (own disclosure page), verified None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
nib nz limitedtrades as nib nzQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewOwn brand onlyStandard & Poor'sAnib NZ (own disclosure page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026No overall acceptance rate on the public pages captured
Partners Life Limitedtrades as Partners LifeQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewOwn brand onlyA.M. BestA (Excellent)Partners Life (own disclosure page), verified 95% of all assessed claims, Apr 2024 – Mar 2025
Pinnacle Life Limited (NZBN 9429030397248)trades as Pinnacle LifeMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureNZ Seniors, OneChoiceA.M. BestB+Pinnacle Life (own disclosure page), verified None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Police Health Plan Limitedtrades as Police Health PlanMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyA.M. BestA-Reserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
PPS Mutual Limitedtrades as PPS MutualMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyA.M. BestB+Reserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Resolution Life Australasia Limitedtrades as Resolution Life AustralasiaMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyFitchAA-Reserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Resolution Life New Zealand Limitedtrades as Resolution Life NZMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyFitchAResolution Life (own financial strength page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.
Southern Cross Medical Care Societytrades as Southern Cross Health SocietyQuoteHub panel insurer, see our disclosureQuoteHub reviewOwn brand onlyStandard & Poor'sA+ (Strong)Southern Cross Health Society (own disclosure page), verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026No acceptance rate published; $1.498 billion returned in claims, FY24
Southsure Assurance Limitedtrades as Southsure AssuranceMarket information only, not named on QuoteHub’s disclosureOwn brand onlyFitchBBB+Reserve Bank of New Zealand, verified date not published, verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026None captured in QuoteHub’s evidence register, recorded as a gap, not a zero.

The three scales side by side

Each agency’s own ladder, top to bottom, and the grades the eight panel insurers hold on it. The Reserve Bank’s

register of licensed insurers

records the grade each insurer holds from an agency; the scales are the agencies’ own.

A.M. Best’s ladderMomentum Life’s financial strength disclosureS&P Global Ratings DefinitionsFitch’s rating definitionsAsteron Life’s disclosure
AgencyThe scale, top to bottomWhere QuoteHub panel insurers sit
A.M. Best (Financial Strength Rating)Secure: A++ and A+ (Superior), A and A- (Excellent), B++ and B+ (Good) (A.M. Best’s guide). Vulnerable: B and B- (Fair), C++ and C+ (Marginal), C and C- (Weak), D (Poor). E is regulatory supervision, F is liquidation and S is a suspended rating.Chubb Life and Partners Life A (Excellent), Fidelity Life A- (Excellent), Momentum Life B (Fair), which is in the vulnerable range.
S&P Global Ratings (insurer financial strength)AAA (extremely strong), AA (very strong), A (strong), BBB (good), BB (marginal), B (weak), CCC (very weak), CC (extremely weak), then SD and D for default.Southern Cross A+ (Strong), nib A.
Fitch Ratings (insurer financial strength)AAA (Exceptionally Strong), AA (Very Strong), A (Strong), BBB (Good), BB (Moderately Weak), B (Weak), CCC (Very Weak), CC (Extremely Weak), C (Distressed).AIA AA, Asteron Life A+.

Momentum Life: the rating, the solvency and what it does not publish

Momentum Life Limited (FSP472286) is a licensed New Zealand life insurer owned by DCG Invest; A.M. Best says the purchase closed in July 2025. Its A.M. Best rating is B (Fair), which sits in A.M. Best’s “vulnerable” range. The rating was cut from B++ in February 2025 and affirmed at B (Fair) on 11 February 2026. Momentum’s own solvency disclosure shows 107% at 30 June 2026, a margin of about $0.6 million, down from 117% a year earlier (page read 17 October 2026). Policies bought before 14 March 2018 are insured by Fidelity Life.

Two cautions keep that in proportion. The rating is, in Momentum’s own words, “not a recommendation to buy or hold insurance”, and it is an agency’s opinion, not a statement that any claim will or will not be paid. And Momentum Life publishes no claims acceptance rate, so there is no figure here to set against the other insurers’. If you are weighing Momentum Life’s Quick Life ($50,000 to $300,000 to start) or Funeral Insurance ($3,000 to $30,000), compare the grades in the tables above and what each policy pays in the first two years. The

Momentum Life rating page

explains the grade in more detail.

The brand question: who actually underwrites the advertising

The RBNZ register lists legal entities, not brands, and some of the most heavily advertised names in NZ insurance are not on it, because they are marketing brands whose policies are issued by a different company. When a claim is paid, it is paid from the underwriter’s balance sheet; the brand’s rating, in every meaningful sense, is its underwriter’s rating. The table states each verified brand’s underwriter from the brand’s own legal disclosure.

Direct-to-consumer brands and the licensed insurer that issues their policies. A brand has no rating of its own, the rating that matters is its underwriter’s, shown here attributed to the underwriter by name with a linked source in each cell.

BrandPolicies issued byWhose rating appliesBrand’s own disclosure
Southern Cross Life InsuranceSouthern Cross Insurance Services Limited (promoter - not an insurer)Chubb Life NZChubb Life NZ: A (Excellent) (A.M. Best)southerncrosslife.co.nz legal disclosure, retrieved 15 August 2026
AA LifeNew Zealand Automobile Association (Incorporated) (distributor - not an insurer)Asteron LifeAsteron Life: A+ (Fitch)aalife.co.nz, retrieved 15 August 2026
NZ SeniorsGreenstone Financial Services NZ Limited (NZBN 9429047013582) (distributor/promoter)Pinnacle LifePinnacle Life: B+ (A.M. Best)nzseniors.co.nz, retrieved 15 August 2026
OneChoiceGreenstone Financial Services NZ Limited (distributor/promoter)Pinnacle LifePinnacle Life: B+ (A.M. Best)onechoice.co.nz, retrieved 15 August 2026

Laid against the advised market, the spread is the widest fact in this report. Seven of the eight insurers on QuoteHub’s advice panel each hold an A-band grade from their agency, from Fidelity Life’s A- (Excellent), A.M. Best, affirmed 5 March 2026 to AIA’s AA (Very Strong), Fitch Ratings. The eighth, Momentum Life, is on the panel through an online-application partnership and holds B (Fair) from A.M. Best, affirmed 11 February 2026 after a downgrade from B++ in February 2025; B ratings sit in A.M. Best’s “vulnerable” range. In the direct-only market, Pinnacle Life, the licensed insurer behind NZ Seniors and OneChoice as well as its own brand, holds B+ (Good) from A.M. Best, affirmed 15 April 2026. On A.M. Best’s own scale Momentum Life’s grade and Pinnacle Life’s sit three and two notches below the A-band, in the “Fair” and “Good” categories respectively.

Stated carefully: a B+ or B rated insurer is licensed, supervised by the Reserve Bank, and has an agency opinion that it can meet its obligations, a rating is not a prediction of failure, and this report draws no conclusion about which policy anyone should hold. What the data does show is an information asymmetry: the direct brands advertise hardest to the consumers least likely to read an underwriting disclosure, their television and mail campaigns name neither the issuing insurer nor its grade, and two brands with near-identical marketing (AA Life and NZ Seniors, say) can sit on underwriters at opposite ends of the verified range. The underwriter’s identity and rating are exactly the facts a buyer cannot see in the ad, which is why this report and the explorer publish them plainly.

The scale of it: what published claims add up to

Summing only the published figures in the transparency table, Southern Cross’s $1.498 billion returned in claims in FY24, AIA’s $829.6 million in 2024, Partners Life’s more than $325 million in the year to March 2025, Fidelity Life’s $247.7 million in the year to June 2025 and Asteron Life’s $112 million in the year to June 2024 , gives $3.01 billion paid by five insurers. Three caveats keep that number honest. The five periods are different twelve-month windows, Asteron’s ends in June 2024, AIA’s in December 2024, Partners’ in March 2025, Fidelity’s in June 2025, and Southern Cross publishes its figure against its own FY24, so this is not a single-year market total. AIA’s figure includes GST, maturities and surrenders, and Partners publishes a floor (“more than”), so the components are not measured identically. And the sum omits every insurer that publishes no total, including Chubb Life and nib, so as a statement about the whole market it can only be a lower bound.

The longer arcs are published too: Partners Life reports more than $1.6 billion paid since its 2011 launch, and Fidelity Life reports over $1.8 billion paid across its first 50 years (retrieved 15 August 2026). Set against the treatment-cost side of QuoteHub’s research,

private treatment costs and public waiting times

, the claims volume is the other half of the same system: a meaningful share of NZ private healthcare and household income replacement is funded through these payouts.

What this means for consumers

Three practical readings follow from the data. First, if published claims performance matters to you, the five insurers in the transparency table have put a number on the record and the others have not, but compare each number only with its own basis, and treat any single-figure league table as a red flag in whatever you are reading. Second, if you hold or are considering a policy from a direct brand, find out which licensed insurer issues it, the brand’s own disclosure page states it, and the tables above link each one, because that is whose rating and claims practice stand behind your cover. Third, neither a rating nor an acceptance percentage predicts your claim: individual outcomes turn on the policy wording, the disclosures made at application time, and the facts of the event, which is what the claims readiness checker helps you prepare for.

A fourth reading applies if you cannot get cover with health questions, or do not want to answer them. Guaranteed acceptance cover exists for that (see

guaranteed acceptance life insurance

and what it means, and funeral insurance), but every such policy restricts the first one to two years, and a healthy person can usually get more cover for less through a licensed adviser with health questions answered. Momentum Life’s Quick Life and Funeral Insurance are the two such products QuoteHub can point you to, and the buttons on this page lead to Momentum Life’s own online application. Because those policies restrict the early years, no acceptance rate would describe them fairly even if Momentum Life published one. You can also read

what happens if you have no life insurance at all

or

how to change cover without losing it

.

If this data raises questions about cover you already hold, who underwrites it, how its insurer’s strength compares, or how a claim would actually run, a licensed adviser can review it against the market: book a free review or start with our insurer comparison. This page does not recommend any insurer. QuoteHub is a Momentum Life partner, and Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver may receive a commission if you buy through the Momentum Life buttons; our how we are paid page explains it.

Methodology

This report uses public-source data only: no QuoteHub customer, enquiry or CRM data appears anywhere in it. This is the permanent URL for the report, future editions update this page in place, with each change recorded in the changelog below, so citations keep resolving.

Claims statistics

  • Every claims figure is transcribed from the insurer’s own published claims page, media release or claims brochure, with the basis, product scope and period carried alongside the number, never derived, never averaged across insurers, and never taken from a third-party league table. The primary sources: AIA Claims Compass press release and AIA claims page (retrieved 18 August 2026), Asteron Life media release of 11 December 2024 (retrieved 18 August 2026), the “This is Partners Life 2025” claims brochure (retrieved 18 August 2026), Fidelity Life’s “Claims we’ve paid” page (retrieved 15 August 2026), Chubb Life’s 2024 claims statistics and life insurance page (retrieved 18 August 2026), and Southern Cross’s About page (retrieved 18 August 2026).
  • Comparability: the published figures use four distinct denominators, all claims received (AIA), claims received in three product categories (Asteron), assessed claims (Partners), new claims (Fidelity), plus percentages with no stated denominator (Chubb). Periods are five different twelve-month windows. This report therefore presents the figures side by side with their bases and never ranks, charts or averages them; the AIA CY2025 figure additionally carries a source-quality caveat (a claims-page figure attributed to AIA’s business Insights Team, not a published report).
  • Gaps: an insurer with no published claims statistic is recorded as a gap, never estimated and never treated as a zero. That covers Southern Cross and nib (no overall acceptance rate on the pages captured) and the ten smaller licensed insurers for which QuoteHub’s register holds no published claims statistic. Momentum Life is one of the ten; its own pages were checked again on 17 October 2026 and still show none.
  • Update trigger: claims statistics refresh when each insurer publishes its next annual release; each refresh is a new edition of this page with a changelog entry.

Financial strength ratings

  • Ratings render from QuoteHub’s evidence register, which records each grade with its agency, source URL and verification date, cross-checked against the RBNZ register of licensed insurers on 15 August 2026. The RBNZ register records current grades without effective dates, so effective dates come from agency press releases or the insurer’s own statutory disclosure page; where none is published the gap is stated in the cell.
  • Ratings are a high-risk claim class: they sit on a 90-day review cycle (next scheduled review by 13 November 2026) and are re-checked against the register on the day any edition of this page is published. Agencies re-rate insurers between our reviews, always confirm a current grade against the register or the insurer’s own disclosure before relying on it.
  • A rating belongs to the licensed entity, never to a marketing brand: brand rows resolve to their underwriter and the grade is attributed to the underwriter by name. Grades are shown only against their own agency’s scale, no composite score, no cross-agency ranking, no “best”.
  • Exclusions: the RBNZ register lists 79 licensed insurers, most of them general insurers outside this report’s life-and-health scope. Within scope, insurers whose facts are not yet verified to publication standard are excluded and recorded as gaps in QuoteHub’s register, as of 15 August 2026 that includes UniMed (rating outlook and effective date awaiting confirmation), Booster Assurance and Tiaki Toa (business details unverified; no rating required per the register), and Hallmark Life and Beneficial Insurance (product status unverified). Exclusion is a verification state, not an editorial judgement about the insurer.
  • Limitations: all claims figures are insurer-published and unaudited by QuoteHub; a rating is an agency opinion, not a guarantee; and no premium (insurance price) figures appear anywhere in this report or its dataset.

Download the dataset

The dataset behind this report is a single CSV, one row per verified licensed NZ life and health insurer (17 rows), public-source data only: qh-claims-strength-2026.csv.

Field definitions for qh-claims-strength-2026.csv.

FieldDefinition
insurer_legal_entityThe licensed insurer’s legal entity name as recorded on the RBNZ register.
trading_nameThe name the insurer trades under, where it differs from the legal entity.
on_quotehub_panelTRUE if the insurer is named on QuoteHub’s disclosure page as a panel insurer; FALSE or UNKNOWN otherwise.
brands_underwrittenVerified direct-to-consumer brands whose policies this insurer issues (semicolon-separated), or "own brand only".
rating_agencyThe agency that issued the financial strength rating.
rating_gradeThe grade exactly as recorded, with the agency’s descriptor where published.
rating_outlookThe published outlook, where recorded. May be empty.
rating_effective_dateISO date the rating was affirmed or issued, or UNKNOWN where no date is published.
rating_source_urlDirect URL of the rating’s primary source (insurer statutory disclosure or RBNZ register).
rating_verified_dateISO date QuoteHub last verified the grade against its source and the RBNZ register.
claims_metricThe insurer’s published claims-outcome statistic transcribed as stated, or NOT-PUBLISHED (no overall rate on pages captured) or NOT-CAPTURED (no published statistic in QuoteHub’s register).
claims_basisWhat the metric counts: the denominator (claims received / assessed / new), product scope and known inclusions. The bases differ across insurers, do not rank metrics.
claims_periodThe twelve-month window the metric covers, as the insurer states it.
claims_paid_totalThe published dollars paid in that period, transcribed as stated. May be empty.
claims_source_urlDirect URL of the claims statistic’s primary source. May be empty.
claims_retrieved_dateISO date the claims source was last retrieved by QuoteHub. May be empty.
notesCaveats that travel with the row (e.g. secondary-year figures, denominator-not-stated warnings). May be empty.

Citing this report

This report may be cited freely with attribution. Suggested citation:

QuoteHub Claims & Insurer Strength Report, August 2026. QuoteHub, www.quotehub.co.nz/research/claims-insurer-strength.

Media enquiries are welcome via the QuoteHub contact page; a licensed financial adviser is available for comment on the data. Anyone reusing the claims figures should carry the basis and period with the number, the comparability caveats in the methodology are part of the finding, not fine print.

Changelog and corrections

  • 18 August 2026, first edition published (claims sources re-checked 18 August 2026; ratings verified against the RBNZ register 15 August 2026).
  • 15 October 2026, correction: Momentum Life is on QuoteHub’s advice panel through an online-application partnership, so the panel statements now read seven of eight A-band, with Momentum Life at B (Fair), and the on_quotehub_panel field for Momentum Life in the CSV moved from UNKNOWN to TRUE. No rating or claims figure changed.
  • 20 October 2026, update: added Momentum Life to the claims table as an insurer that publishes no claims statistics; added Momentum Life’s solvency and ownership (from its own disclosure, read 17 October 2026); added the three rating scales side by side and a section on why claims are not paid. No other rating or claims figure changed.

Material corrections are noted on this page rather than made silently, per

QuoteHub’s editorial and corrections policy

.

About this report

This report is general information, not personalised financial advice, and nothing in it predicts the outcome of any claim or recommends any insurer. QuoteHub’s advice panel, the insurers our advisers can place cover with, is listed on our disclosure page; every other insurer appears as market information only. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). Claims sources re-checked 18 August 2026; ratings last verified 15 August 2026.

About the numbers

Insurer disclosures, rating agency grades and the Reserve Bank register, each linked.

A grade belongs to the licensed entity that carries the risk. This report is not a recommendation. See how QuoteHub checks a figure before publishing it.

A couple going through figures with an adviser, a laptop and calculator on the table.

Want the result checked by a licensed adviser?

Free, no obligation. Licensed New Zealand advisers.

Free, no obligation. Same price as going direct. Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.