Reserve Bank orders eight insurers to model their own failure in first such test

Updated

Written by

Reviewed by Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver Licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931)

Our editorial process

Read this article with AI:

Photo for the story: Reserve Bank orders eight insurers to model their own failure in first such test

The three largest health insurers join the five largest life insurers, with results due in the last three months of 2026.

The Reserve Bank has told New Zealand's three largest health insurers and five largest life insurers to work backwards from their own failure, it said in a bulletin.

It is called a reverse stress test. The ending is fixed: the insurer's spare capital falls below the legal minimum, known as the solvency margin. Each insurer then writes the chain of events that gets it there.

Answers were due in July, and the findings are published in the last three months of 2026. It is the first such test to include health insurers.

The Bank hasn't named the eight. Its three-year testing plan, published on 13 April, covers "the five largest life insurers that participated in the inaugural 2022 Life Insurance Industry Stress Test, plus the three largest health insurers for the first time".

The 2022 participants were AIA, Asteron Life, Chubb Life, Fidelity Life and Partners Life. On health, Southern Cross calls itself the largest insurer, and UniMed said in 2024 it was the third largest, with 10% of the market. That leaves nib, which is our guess, not the Bank's.

Health insurers got tighter instructions, because of "ongoing concerns that claims costs may increase at a rate exceeding wage growth and general inflation".

That trend, the Bank said, "may place sustained pressure on profitability and create uncertainty regarding the adequacy and acceptability of premium increases for policyholders and employers".

The Bank's May Financial Stability Report says health premiums are up 15% to 30% over two years. It also says the sector is under "a period of more intensive supervision".

Insurers are responding by trimming benefits, negotiating harder with providers, and adding co-payments and ceilings on what they'll pay for a given fee, the report says.

Southern Cross's 2025 results show the squeeze. Claims took 94 cents of every premium dollar, with $1.706 billion paid out on $1.811 billion collected.

Health insurance still ran a $56.9 million shortfall.

At nib New Zealand, premiums grew 12.1% to $218.0 million in the first half of 2025, nib reported. Claims costs rose 17.6%, and an underlying $13.0 million profit became a $10.9 million loss.

The only earlier life insurance test, in 2022, gave every insurer the same scenario. All five stayed solvent.

By year three their combined solvency margin was "over 50% lower" than normal, still "well above the regulatory minimum of zero", the Bank reported.

The Bank tried a reverse test on banks in 2024. Several found no single event broke them, only a combination.

The May report also singles out income protection sold to individuals as the biggest drag on life insurers' returns, driven by rising mental health claims. It expects insurers "to proactively assess the long-term sustainability" of those products.

More on health insurance and income protection cover.

What a policy pays, how to size it, and how a rule change reaches an existing policy. Life insurance in New Zealand

This story is general information only. It isn't financial advice and doesn't take your circumstances, health or existing cover into account. Policy terms, conditions, exclusions and stand-down periods apply and can change. QuoteHub usually doesn't charge you for advice and may receive commission from insurers; our disclosure statement explains how we're paid.

Sources

Corrections · How we report the news

Wondering whether this affects your cover?

Book a cover review

Free, no obligation. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). Disclosure statement

Start your free comparison

Compare panel options first. A licensed NZ adviser can then review existing cover or help with an application.

Free, no obligation. Licensed NZ advisers · Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.