Buy-Sell Agreement Funding in NZ: Who Pays for the Shares
A buy-sell agreement says who must buy a departing owner's shares, at what price, if that owner dies, is permanently disabled or is diagnosed with a serious illness. It is funded by life, TPD and trauma policies written over each owner for the value of their shares, so the cash arrives when the obligation does. Without the cover, the survivors must find the money from savings, borrowing or the business itself.
In short
- Insure each owner for the agreed value of their shares: life for death, TPD for permanent disability, trauma for serious illness.
- Choose who owns the policies before you write the clause. It decides who receives the claim and how the tax works.
- Name a valuation method and an independent valuer, not a fixed number. Re-check the sums insured every year.
How the cover funds the purchase
Each owner is insured for the value of their own shares. Your agreement then names the event that forces the sale, and the policy needs to answer the same event.
| Trigger | Policy | Clause to get right |
|---|---|---|
| Death | Life cover | Put and call options, so the estate must sell and the survivors must buy |
| Permanent disability | TPD cover | Define "permanent disability" in the agreement to match the policy definition, or you may be forced to buy with no claim to fund it |
| Serious illness | Trauma cover | Decide whether a trauma claim forces a sale, or only a right to sell if the owner cannot return to work |
Whether you can insure a co-owner is settled: a life policy is not void by reason only that the insured has no interest in that life. Expect heavier underwriting than personal cover. The sum insured has to be justified with the valuation, financial statements and an accountant's letter.
Who should own the policies
Three structures are used in New Zealand. The choice changes the tax position and who controls the policy.
Self-ownership. Each owner owns the policy on their own life, and the agreement obliges their estate to sell. It works at any number of shareholders. The trade-off is that the money lands in the estate first, and estate debts are paid before anything is distributed.
Cross-ownership. Each owner holds a policy on the others, so the claim pays directly to the person who has to buy. It is clean with two owners and unwieldy past three: with three owners it takes six policies (each owner insures the other two), with four it takes twelve, and every sum insured must move whenever the valuation does. With three or more owners, weigh self-ownership against the policy count before you choose cross-ownership. The policy owner keeps it in force and decides where claims are paid, and the life assured cannot cancel cover on their own life without the owner's agreement.
Company ownership. The company owns and pays, and the claim lands in the company. It is simplest to administer and hardest on tax. In QB 17/06, a key-person statement, Inland Revenue says premiums are not deductible where an employer takes out a policy on behalf of its shareholders in case one of them dies, because the benefit accrues to the shareholders rather than the company. Confirm the treatment of your own structure with your accountant. For the mirror image, see key person cover and business life insurance tax.
Valuation clauses, and why a fixed figure ages badly
Findex's corporate finance team notes that agreements which hard-code a valuation methodology risk an answer that is obsolete, because the multiple applied to maintainable earnings tracks the risk of the business, and that risk moves with customer concentration, key-person dependence and industry conditions. A figure agreed when one client supplied half the revenue is wrong once the client base broadens.
Name the method and the referee, not the number. State the basis, provide for an independent valuer, fix a review date, and re-check the sums insured against the new valuation the same day.
A worked example
Hypothetical, using round valuation figures rather than premiums. Two engineers own a Tauranga consultancy 50/50. Their agreement uses capitalisation of maintainable earnings, requires an independent valuer and sets a review each March. At the last review the business was valued at $1,800,000, so each parcel was worth $900,000, and each owner holds $900,000 of cover on the other under cross-ownership.
Owner B dies in September. B's shares pass to the estate, the executor applies for probate, and the estate serves its put notice. A's policy pays $900,000 straight to A, A pays the estate, the transfer is registered, and A owns the company outright. B's family gets cash, not a shareholding they cannot sell.
Now change one fact. The firm won a large contract and was worth $2,400,000 by September, and nobody re-ran the valuation. The agreement still obliges A to pay $1,200,000 while the policy delivers $900,000. A funds the $300,000 gap personally, borrows it, or asks a grieving family to accept instalments.
What the agreement obliges each side to do
A workable agreement is a matched pair of options. The departing owner or their estate holds a put option that forces the survivors to buy, and the survivors hold a call option that forces the estate to sell. With only one, either side can decline to transact.
Five clauses do the real work: trigger events, valuation method, funding and policy ownership, settlement timetable, and the treatment of shareholder current accounts and personal guarantees. The last is the one most often missed. A departing owner is usually owed money through their current account and often personally guarantees the bank facility and the lease, and buying their shares releases neither. The agreement must also match the constitution, since a share is transferable only subject to any restriction on transfer set out there.
Why an unfunded agreement is a promise nobody can keep
When a shareholder dies the shares do not revert to the survivors. They may pass by operation of law whatever the constitution says, and the personal representative may transfer them. First the executor must prove their authority. Probate is a High Court order confirming the will is valid, and without it many organisations will not release the deceased's property.
So the survivors negotiate with an executor whose duty runs to the beneficiaries, not the business. The board cannot simply stall. It may refuse or delay registering a transfer only if it resolves to do so within 30 working days of receiving it, gives its reasons, notifies both parties within 5 working days, and the Act or the constitution expressly permits refusal on those grounds.
If the standoff hardens, the remaining route is court. A shareholder who considers the company's affairs oppressive, unfairly discriminatory or unfairly prejudicial may apply to the court, which can order the company or any other person to acquire the shares, or order liquidation.
If the company buys the shares back
If the company buys the shares itself, it is acquiring its own shares, and the Act prescribes the route. A company may do so only if its constitution expressly permits it. An offer to one shareholder rather than all needs either the written consent of every shareholder, or express constitutional permission plus the special-offer procedure. The board must resolve that the acquisition benefits the remaining shareholders and the terms are fair and reasonable to them, and sign a certificate saying so. A disclosure document goes to every shareholder, and the offer must follow not less than 10 working days and not more than 12 months after it is sent.
The company must satisfy the solvency test: able to pay its debts as they become due, with assets exceeding liabilities including contingent liabilities. Notice reaches the Registrar within 10 working days. The shares are deemed cancelled on acquisition, unless the constitution expressly permits the company to hold its own shares, the board resolves not to cancel them, and the holding stays within 5% of that class.
Cancellation is the control trade-off. A buyback lifts every remaining shareholder's percentage in proportion to what they already held, while a cross-owned or self-owned purchase lets the survivors decide who buys how much.
Putting it in place
Work in this order. Read the constitution and any existing shareholders' agreement first, because the transfer and pre-emption clauses set the boundaries. Agree the valuation basis with your accountant. Have a lawyer draft the agreement, including the current-account and guarantee clauses. Only then set the sums insured and choose the ownership structure, so the cover matches the document.
To see how life, TPD and trauma cover would sit across your shareholding, start a comparison and talk it through with a licensed adviser. It is free to you, and insurers pay us a commission if you take a policy. See also business protection, shareholder protection insurance and the business insurance hub.
Disclaimer: General information only, not personalised financial, legal or tax advice. Buy-sell agreements should be drafted by a lawyer and the tax treatment confirmed with your accountant. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931).
References
- Companies Act 1993, s 39 (transferability of shares)
- Companies Act 1993, s 52 (distributions) and s 4 (solvency test)
- Companies Act 1993, ss 58 to 67A (company acquiring and holding its own shares)
- Companies Act 1993, s 84 (transfer of shares) and s 86 (transfer by operation of law)
- Companies Act 1993, s 174 (prejudiced shareholders)
- Insurance Law Reform Act 1985, s 6 (insurable interest in a life policy)
- Inland Revenue, QB 17/06: Income tax, insurance, key-person insurance policies
- Ministry of Justice, probate information and guidance
- Findex, share valuation clauses in shareholder agreements, 19 March 2021
- Partners Life, what is policy ownership and why does it matter
- Companies Act 1993, s 86
- s 59(1)
- s 60(1)(b)
- s 61(1) and (3)
- s 4
- s 66(1)
- s 67A
Read the full insurance guides
Explore related pages: Life Insurance, Income Protection, Health Insurance, Trauma Insurance, Calculators.