The New Zealand Gynaecology Association has asked the Commerce Commission for permission to negotiate as one group with Southern Cross and with hospitals, the Commission said on 25 May.
The trigger is that Southern Cross has proposed changes to the contracts tying together patients, hospitals, the insurer and gynaecologists.
Competition law normally stops rivals agreeing on a price. The Commission can allow it under section 58 of the Commerce Act 1986 if the public gains more than it loses.
The doctors want a group agreement that can run up to ten years, with a six-month pause first so members don't sign their own deals in the meantime.
Southern Cross has more than 945,000 members, roughly 60% of the health insurance market by customer numbers. The Commission says it pays 68% of the value of all health insurance claims paid in New Zealand.
Submissions closed on 9 June. The Commission set 22 October 2026 as its deadline to decide, and its public case file lists the case as open with no outcome recorded.
Southern Cross Health Insurance told the Commission the application is "an attempt by a concentrated group of highly paid specialists to avoid competitive price discipline", Newsroom reported on 8 July.
If more than 90 percent of private gynaecology surgeons set prices together, it argues, the result is "sustained upward pressure on gynaecology surgery prices" that flows "directly to members through premium increases, affordability pressure, reduced policy cover".
Its 2025 annual report summary shows it handed back more than 94% of premiums as claims, and made a $56.9 million health insurance deficit.
The association says the proposed procedure codes leave out pelvic floor disorders and gynaecological cancers. It says they "prevent clinicians from combining procedures in a single operation, forcing some women into multiple surgeries".
Association president Dr Lakshmi Ravikanti called the margins accusation "both inaccurate and a disappointing distraction".
The association says it isn't trying to block the proposal, only to have it settled with proper clinical and market input, according to an earlier Newsroom report on 30 June.
Southern Cross's hospital company told the Commission in a submission that bundled pricing is "the prevailing model of healthcare funding in New Zealand and internationally". It says it has been in provider contracts "since about 1997".
nib told the Commission the price settled here "is likely to become a floor for the remainder of the private health care market, whether funded by other health insurance companies or self-funded by patients", in its own submission.
Southern Cross says most of its policies include some services that are "Affiliated Provider-only", and members "are only eligible for cover if they visit an Affiliated Provider", according to its member FAQ.
More on health insurance cover.



