Some add-on insurance sold in New Zealand pays out just 3 to 6 cents in claims for every dollar of premium, the Financial Markets Authority found in a review published on 20 August.
The FMA estimates about 500,000 of these policies are in force, going by customer numbers insurers reported themselves. Nine insurers stand behind them, and it reviewed seven, including all the larger providers.
The review looked at four kinds of cover: mechanical breakdown insurance, GAP cover, consumer credit and payment protection insurance, and extended warranties on appliances.
Payout rates on GAP, consumer credit and payment protection cover were consistently low, and some sat below 20%. Certain products ran at 3% to 6%. Insurers call this the loss ratio.
The report doesn't name the insurers or products, or say which figure belongs to which.
The sharpest criticism is of supervision. Insurers could describe how they sign up and train the dealers and brokers who sell for them. The review found little evidence they kept checking afterwards in a way that matched the risk.
What checking there was often wasn't independent. In some cases the people meant to be watching the sellers were the same people whose job was driving sales.
Michael Hewes, the FMA's Director of Credit, Deposit-taking, Insurance and Advice, said the review found "a recurring gap between the policies, processes, systems and controls insurers described and how they operated in practice", in an FMA media release.
The FMA's four concerns come down to one: people may be sold things they do not need, do not understand, or already hold, and insurers aren't consistently catching it.
The FMA now takes the view that some extended warranties count as insurance contracts. That brings them under the Conduct of Financial Institutions regime, the law requiring banks and insurers to treat customers fairly.
Nothing in the review changes what existing cover pays out.
Every one of these sales pays a commission, and so does most life and health cover in New Zealand. The FMA hasn't said life or health insurers are doing what it criticised in add-ons.
The FMA's earlier study, Replacing life insurance, who benefits?, found that when overseas trips were on offer for hitting sales targets, life policies old enough that the adviser no longer had to repay any commission were 2.2 times more likely to be replaced.
In its Financial Conduct Report 2026/27, the FMA said firms were still inconsistent about telling clients what commission they and the adviser were paid, and what happens to it if a policy is cancelled early.
Under the Financial Markets Conduct Regulations 2014, an advice firm must tell clients who pays each commission, who receives it, and either the amount or how it is worked out.



