FMA makes adviser commissions one of its four priorities for 2026/27

Updated

Written by

Reviewed by Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver Licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931)

Our editorial process

Read this article with AI:

Photo for the story: FMA makes adviser commissions one of its four priorities for 2026/27

A 2016 FMA report found policies paying advisers a big sale commission were more likely to be replaced once the two year clawback ended.

The Financial Markets Authority has named the way advisers are paid as one of four priorities for 2026/27, and says it is aware of high upfront commissions on life, health and disability cover.

The regulator set out its priorities on 30 June. Conflicts created by adviser pay sit alongside product design, complaints handling and fraud.

On pay, the FMA says it will look at whether firms have real controls over those conflicts. It also wants to know whether they can "detect and deter misconduct that may be incentivised by commission-based relationships".

The Financial Conduct Report 2026/27 says the FMA is aware of "high upfront commissions for financial advice across life, health and disability insurance products" that increase the risk of consumer harm.

Its monitoring last year found firms were inconsistent about telling customers the actual commission payable, and about clawbacks. Advisers also missed signs a customer was vulnerable, such as being unwell, elderly or under money pressure.

The FMA links that to "the sale of unsuitable products and inappropriate replacement business driven by commission incentives".

Clawback is the rule that makes an adviser repay part of their sale payment if a policy is cancelled early. In the FMA's 2016 report, Replacing life insurance, who benefits?, it usually ran two years.

That report found policies that paid a large sum on sale and a small amount each year after were 1.6 times more likely to be replaced once the window closed. How good the product was came into it only as "a minor factor".

It also named that upfront structure as the most common one here. The sale payment was up to 200% of the first year's premium, against 5% to 7% a year after, which by our sums is 29 to 40 years of looking after a policy.

A later review by the FMA and the Reserve Bank found sale payments commonly ran between 170% and 210% of first-year premiums, in its 2019 conduct report.

The FMA does not publish current commission rates, so those percentages come from reports published in 2016 and 2019.

New rules from 31 March 2025 ban incentives tied to a sales target, such as a $1,000 bonus for selling at least 100 life policies in three months. They allow a commission set as a fixed percentage of first-year premium, paid one policy at a time, under the Financial Markets Conduct Regulations 2014.

Those regulations also say an adviser's firm must tell clients each commission's amount or how it is worked out, when it is paid, who pays and receives it, and how the conflict is managed.

What a policy pays, how to size it, and how a rule change reaches an existing policy. Life insurance in New Zealand

This story is general information only. It isn't financial advice and doesn't take your circumstances, health or existing cover into account. Policy terms, conditions, exclusions and stand-down periods apply and can change. QuoteHub usually doesn't charge you for advice and may receive commission from insurers; our disclosure statement explains how we're paid.

Sources

Corrections · How we report the news

Wondering whether this affects your cover?

Book a cover review

Free, no obligation. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). Disclosure statement

Start your free comparison

Compare panel options first. A licensed NZ adviser can then review existing cover or help with an application.

Free, no obligation. Licensed NZ advisers · Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.