Reserve Bank draft law proposes $2.5 million fines for insurers that break solvency rules

Updated

Written by

Reviewed by Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver Licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931)

Our editorial process

Read this article with AI:

Photo for the story: Reserve Bank draft law proposes $2.5 million fines for insurers that break solvency rules

The same draft lets the government cut policy values in a rescue without a vote in Parliament, and we found no compensation promised.

The Reserve Bank has published a draft law that would let a court fine an insurer up to $2,500,000 each time it breaks a solvency rule, without a criminal case.

It put the exposure draft out on 15 April. Comments close at 5pm on 28 August, and it is not law yet.

Today the Reserve Bank's only way to punish an insurer that breaks those rules is a criminal prosecution. The draft adds a civil penalty, capped at $2,500,000 for a company and $300,000 for an individual.

The current criminal maximum is $1,000,000 for a company, or $200,000 or three months in prison for an individual. Trading as an insurer without a licence would rise to $2,500,000, with up to 18 months in prison.

The Reserve Bank doesn't expect any of the new rules to start before late 2028.

The fine is a flat cap. For a bank, the same regulator can seek the greater of $5,000,000 and 0.1% of total assets under the Deposit Takers Act.

When Dai-ichi Life bought Partners Life in 2022, it published accounts showing total assets of $1,322 million. By our sums, $2,500,000 is about 0.19% of that.

Conduct is policed harder. The Financial Markets Authority can already seek the greatest of what the customer paid, three times the firm's gain, or $5,000,000 under the Financial Markets Conduct Act.

Deep in the 121-page draft is a second power. If the Reserve Bank were rescuing a failed or failing insurer, the Governor-General, acting on the government's advice, could sign off a cut to what policies are worth. No vote in Parliament is needed.

That sits in Schedule 2, clause 55 of the draft bill. We found nothing in the draft promising the policyholder compensation.

The rescue process is a resolution regime copied from the rules for banks. Its first stated purpose is to protect policyholders' interests, according to the Reserve Bank's consultation paper.

The draft doesn't change where policyholders rank if an insurer fails. A life insurer must keep a statutory fund, a walled-off pot of assets that pays life claims before the fund's other creditors, once the liquidator has taken its costs.

Health and general policyholders have no such pot. Their claims rank as ordinary debts alongside every supplier the company owes.

Unlike bank depositors under the Deposit Takers Act 2023, policyholders have no compensation scheme standing behind them, and the draft doesn't create one.

More on life insurance and health insurance.

This story is general information only. It isn't financial advice and doesn't take your circumstances, health or existing cover into account. Policy terms, conditions, exclusions and stand-down periods apply and can change. QuoteHub usually doesn't charge you for advice and may receive commission from insurers; our disclosure statement explains how we're paid.

Sources

Corrections · How we report the news

Wondering whether this affects your cover?

Book a cover review

Free, no obligation. Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). Disclosure statement

Start your free comparison

Compare panel options first. A licensed NZ adviser can then review existing cover or help with an application.

Free, no obligation. Licensed NZ advisers · Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.