ACC Review and Resolution: What the Payout Data Shows (to 2020/21)

Key answer

ACC's own published figures show that challenging a decision rarely ends in a formal win but often ends in a changed outcome. Of the 9,316 reviews completed in 2020/21, 68% were withdrawn or settled before a hearing, 9% were decided in the client's favour and 23% in ACC's favour. Reviews also take time: ACC's 2023 Annual Report puts the average time to resolution for claims with reviews at 129.7 days. The most recent published outcome breakdown is for 2020/21, so read the percentages as the pattern, not this year's odds.

Most people only think about ACC when something has already gone wrong, and a decision does not look right. Then the big questions start: is it worth asking for a review, what are the odds of a better payout, and should you have your own insurance as a back-up?

This guide walks through what ACC’s own numbers say about review and resolution outcomes, and how that fits with having private cover in place.

How the ACC review system is meant to work

The Accident Compensation Act 2001 sets up a formal, statutory review process for ACC decisions in Part 5, sections 133 to 152. This process is there so you can challenge almost any decision ACC makes about your claim.

A few key points from the law and ACC’s own guidance:

  • Reviews are not done by the original ACC staff member who decided your claim. Section 135A says the reviewer must act independently, and ACC is not allowed to engage as a reviewer anyone who is also involved in making claim decisions in any other role.
  • ACC will often try early resolution first. Their page on how to request an independent review explains that they investigate the claim again and try to resolve it before a full formal review hearing.
  • If that is not possible, you can choose from a list of independent review providers who will look at whether ACC’s decision was correct, based on the law and the evidence.

So in theory, the review process is a safety net that can increase or restore entitlements like weekly compensation or treatment funding. The natural next question is what actually happens in practice.

What ACC’s data says about review outcomes

ACC publishes long-run statistics on reviews in its Financial Condition Report. The figures below are directly from the 2021 report.

For each year ending 30 June 2015 to 2021, ACC records how many reviews were:

  • Lodged (requested)
  • Completed
  • Withdrawn or settled
  • Decided in favour of the client
  • Decided in favour of ACC

Here is a simplified summary of that seven-year run:

  • The number of reviews lodged rose from 6,514 in 2014/15 to 9,329 in 2020/21.
  • The number of reviews completed rose from 6,874 in 2014/15 to 9,316 in 2020/21.

For outcomes, the pattern over time is important:

  • Withdrawn or settled:
    • 2,892 reviews in 2014/15 (42% of completed)
    • climbing to 6,319 reviews in 2020/21 (68% of completed).
  • Found in favour of clients:
    • 1,084 reviews in 2014/15 (16% of completed)
    • dropping to 872 reviews in 2020/21 (9% of completed).
  • Found in favour of ACC:
    • 2,872 reviews in 2014/15 (42% of completed)
    • dropping to 2,106 reviews in 2020/21 (23% of completed).

So over these years, formal “wins” for clients at review became less common as a share of all completed reviews, and more cases ended up withdrawn or settled before a full decision.

That does not mean no one is improving their position, but it does mean most disputes end without a clear, published “client won / ACC lost” decision.

What “withdrawn or settled” might mean for your payout

ACC’s statistics do not spell out how much extra money, if any, clients receive when a review is withdrawn or settled. But from the way the process works, a few reasonable points follow:

  • A withdrawn review can reflect a change of heart on either side. For example, ACC might reconsider and change its decision after more information is supplied, so there is no need to continue. Or a client might withdraw because the evidence is not there.
  • A settled review usually involves some form of agreement between ACC and the client, often with help from alternative dispute resolution like mediation.

ACC has said in an OIA response that in one period over 1000 reviews were referred to alternative dispute resolution to get to a review outcome. That suggests a sizeable chunk of disputes are resolved through negotiation rather than a straight win or loss.

From a payout point of view, that matters because:

  • A formal win at review can reinstate or increase weekly compensation or treatment funding, and sometimes back-pay arrears.
  • A settlement can also lead to more support, but the details are case-by-case and are not captured in headline statistics.

So when you see that only 9% of completed reviews in 2020/21 were decided in favour of clients, that does not mean only 9% of people improved their position. It does mean, though, that the path to improvement is often negotiation rather than a courtroom-style decision.

How long ACC reviews take

ACC’s 2023 Annual Report notes that in 2022/23 the average time to resolution for claims with reviews was 129.7 days, with a target of 130 days.

That is over four months on average from lodging a review through to resolution.

If you are off work or struggling to pay bills, that delay can hurt, even if you eventually get a better outcome. This is one of the reasons some people look at private insurance alongside ACC, so they are not relying on a slow dispute process to keep the household running.

Is it worth challenging an ACC decision?

The data cannot answer this directly, but it gives some clues.

Reasons it can be worth it

  • Material impact: If the decision affects big things like weekly compensation, cover for surgery, or long-term treatment, the potential financial difference over time can be large.
  • Independent check: The law is clear that reviewers must act independently of ACC. For some people, simply having someone outside ACC look at the evidence is important.
  • Room for negotiation: The high proportion of reviews that are withdrawn or settled suggests there is real scope to reach a better position than the original decision, without needing to “win” outright.

Reasons to think carefully

  • Time and energy: With an average resolution time around the 129.7-day mark for claims with reviews, you are signing up for a potentially slow process.
  • No guarantee of a win: Across the 2015 to 2021 period, decisions formally in favour of clients ranged between 9% and 18% of completed reviews each year, while decisions in favour of ACC remained a substantial share.

In practice, most people benefit from getting proper help to weigh their chances and to prepare good medical and factual evidence before lodging a review.

Where private insurance fits alongside ACC

ACC only covers accidents, and only on certain terms. It does not cover most illnesses, or all income loss scenarios. That is where private cover such as income protection, trauma cover, TPD cover and life insurance can come in.

Here is how the ACC review data connects to private insurance decisions.

1. You are exposed while you wait

If you are disputing a decline or a reduction in ACC weekly compensation, you might be waiting months for clarity. Private policies are not instant either, but a well-set-up income protection policy can:

  • Cover income loss from illness as well as accidents.
  • Provide another potential stream of support while ACC issues are being worked through, depending on the policy terms and offsets.

2. ACC might pay less than your actual income

ACC payments are based on rules in legislation, not on keeping your household budget whole. Private mortgage protection or income cover can be designed around your actual commitments, which can reduce the financial pressure if ACC does not fully bridge the gap.

3. Illness is a bigger long-term risk than accidents

The ACC review statistics only look at accidents already within ACC. They say nothing about illness, which is where many of the longest work absences come from. For that risk, ACC is simply not in the frame, and private cover is the main tool.

4. Disputes exist in private insurance too, but the dynamics differ

Private insurers have their own dispute and complaints processes, and you can escalate to external dispute resolution schemes if needed. The important practical difference is that:

  • You can choose which insurer and which policy wording you buy.
  • You can tailor cover types and levels across life, health and disability-style cover to suit your actual risks, rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all public scheme.

Using the numbers to make a plan

Looking across the seven years of ACC data, a few planning themes stand out:

  1. Reviews are not rare. Thousands of reviews are lodged every year, and the number has been rising over time.
  2. Most reviews do not end in a clear-cut win. The majority are withdrawn or settled, and only a minority of completed reviews are decided in favour of clients.
  3. Resolution is slow on average. ACC’s own figure of 129.7 days to resolve claims with reviews points to a medium-term process, not a quick fix.
  4. You have more control over private cover than ACC outcomes. You cannot control whether ACC will back down at early resolution, but you can control whether you have backup income or lump sum support from private policies.

If you are already in a dispute, it can help to separate two tasks:

  • Short-term: Get advice on your ACC options, review rights, and what evidence you need. Community Law and specialist ACC advocates are often good starting points.
  • Medium-term: Once things are stable, review your wider safety net so that next time, you are not relying solely on a long review process. That might mean looking at income, mortgage or business insurance cover as part of a broader plan.

A practical takeaway

ACC’s own data shows that reviews can and do change outcomes, but mostly through negotiated resolution and over several months, not guaranteed wins. For most people, the safest approach is to treat ACC as one support, not the whole plan, and to back it up with thoughtful private cover and good advice before anything goes wrong.

Sources

Show the 5 sources
  1. Accident Compensation Act 2001, Part 5
  2. Accident Compensation Act 2001, s 135A
  3. ACC Financial Condition Report 2021
  4. ACC OIA response GOV-017319
  5. ACC Annual Report 2023

Your next step

Turn the reading into a decision

Read the full insurance guides

Compare your cover with a licensed NZ adviser · free, no obligation.

Start your free comparison

Compare panel options first. A licensed NZ adviser can then review existing cover or help with an application.

Free, no obligation. Licensed NZ advisers · Craig Smith Business Services Limited, FAP FSP712931.

Explore related pages: Life Insurance, Income Protection, Health Insurance, Trauma Insurance, Compare Insurance NZ.