Some New Zealanders with Long Covid are finding their income protection claims declined under mental health exclusions, including one case where a “fatigue-related disorders” sub-clause was used after an earlier ADHD diagnosis, according to Insurance Business NZ.
What is happening with Long Covid and income protection?
Insurance Business NZ reports that some income protection policyholders with Long Covid are having claims declined under mental health exclusions tied to earlier diagnoses, even though Long Covid is not a mental health condition.
Matakana insurance lawyer Tim Gunn, who specialises in income protection cases, told the publication he is seeing more denials where mental health exclusions are being used against people unable to work because of Long Covid, and that he understands there are “numerous people in the same or similar situation” and it may not be limited to one insurer.
Gunn is assembling a group legal action to test how mental health exclusion clauses are applied to Long Covid disablement claims, according to the article.
Long Covid Support Aotearoa, a nationwide patient-led advocacy group established in 2020, brought the cases to light in an October 2026 press release referred to in the same report.
What the wording actually says in the reported cases
In one case described by Insurance Business NZ, Christchurch software engineer Tales Azevedo Alves had his income protection claim declined in August 2026. The insurer relied on a mental health exclusion that captured “fatigue-related disorders”, listed as a sub-category within the policy’s mental health clause, following an earlier ADHD diagnosis.
Azevedo Alves has disputed the decision, arguing Long Covid is a physical post-viral illness. The article notes that “despite Long Covid not being a mental health condition, the insurance companies say they are caught within the wording of those mental health exclusions.”
A second case outlined in the same piece involved Nicola Coombe, whose total and permanent disability claim was declined under an exclusion applied because of a previous experience with anxiety and depression.
In a separate example of how these clauses can be contested, the Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman Scheme (IFSO) describes an income protection complaint where Ms D had a mental health exclusion but claimed on a return of concussion symptoms causing headaches, fatigue and difficulties concentrating and working. The IFSO case note records that the complaint was settled because the insurer agreed to accept the claim.
Advocacy group chair Larisa Hockey, quoted in Insurance Business NZ, said people living with disabling illness “are already dealing with so much” and that a diagnosis from someone’s past should not be used to dismiss what they are going through now.
How common are mental health-related income claims?
Mental health is already a major driver of income protection claims across the market.
A MoneyHub analysis reported by Insurance Business NZ found that mental health conditions represented 32% of all income protection claims in data from one large independent adviser for the 12 months to December 2025, compared with an estimated industry benchmark of about 20 percent.
Conditions grouped under mental health in that review included depression, anxiety, burnout, stress-related disorders and post-traumatic stress disorder among working-age customers who were temporarily unable to work.
If you have questions about how your own income protection policy would treat a mental health or fatigue-related claim, it can help to ask the insurer in writing and keep copies in case of a future dispute.
What does CoFI’s “fair conduct” requirement have to do with this?
Under the Conduct of Financial Institutions (CoFI) regime, which took full effect on 31 March 2025, all licensed insurers must maintain fair conduct programmes, according to a March 2025 Financial Markets Authority media release cited by Insurance Business NZ.
The same Insurance Business report notes that the FMA licensed 46 insurers under the regime, and that whether declining a physical illness claim under a mental health exclusion meets that fair conduct standard has not yet been tested.
Long Covid Support Aotearoa has called on the FMA to review how insurers word and apply mental health exclusions and to ensure assessments are based on evidence rather than diagnostic assumptions. ANZMES Charitable Trust, described as New Zealand’s national advisory body for ME and associated conditions including Long Covid, told Insurance Business NZ that assessments should reflect current medical evidence about biological dysfunction affecting multiple body systems.
People following CoFI and related regulation news may watch to see whether any formal guidance is issued on how insurers should handle Long Covid disablement claims that intersect with mental health exclusions.
What if you are already living with Long Covid?
If you already have Long Covid and hold income protection, life insurance or TPD cover, it is generally safer not to cancel existing cover unless and until replacement cover is in force, because new exclusions or loadings may apply if you reapply.
If your ability to work is affected by Long Covid, checking how your cover interacts with any ACC entitlements can also be part of planning how you would manage a long spell off work.
Sources
- Insurance Business NZ: Long Covid claims denied under income protection mental health exclusions (3 Nov 2026)
- Insurance Business NZ: Mental health now a leading cause of NZ income claims – analysis (12 Mar 2026)
- IFSO: Mental health or concussion? (accessed 2026)
- Good Returns: Long Covid case highlights a new challenge for the insurance industry (4 Nov 2020)



