How do PD Insurance and Petcover actually compare?
Financial advice is provided by Craig Smith Business Services Limited, trading as Smiths Insurance & KiwiSaver, a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FSP712931). QuoteHub is a trading name.
PD Insurance's entry-level Accident Plan and Petcover's entry-level Mid-Range Core plan both cap annual vet-fee cover at $5,000, but the resemblance stops at the excess: PD deducts a flat $100, $150 or $200 per claim and then pays 100% of everything above that up to the limit, while Petcover's Core plan lets you pick an excess of $0, $100 or $200 plus a 10%, 20% or 30% co-payment on top of that on every claim (PD Insurance FAQ page, retrieved 17 September 2026; Petcover Mid-Range PDS, retrieved 17 September 2026). Neither structure is better on the page; they produce different bills depending on how big the claim is. This page compares what PD Insurance and Petcover each publish, from their own current policy wording and PDS documents, not marketing copy. For the full seven-insurer picture, see Compare pet insurance NZ.
The comparison table
Figures are for each insurer's entry-level standalone plan (PD's Accident Plan, Petcover's Mid-Range Core), for a healthy adult dog, current as at 17 September 2026. All figures are drawn from each insurer's own current policy wording or PDS unless the source column names a different page. Disclosure: QuoteHub does not sell these policies on this page. Its licensed advisers may receive commission from an insurer if you take out cover through them.
| Insurer | Underwriter | Plans | Annual limit (entry plan) | Excess | Co-pay | Illness wait | Cruciate wait | Entry age | Pays vet directly | Dental (entry plan) | Multi-pet | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 PD Insurance |
Pacific International Insurance Pty Limited, FSP394846 | Accident, Classic, Deluxe | $5,000 (Accident Plan) | $100 / $150 / $200, per claim (FAQ page) | Not published; PD pays 100% of the claim above the dollar excess, not a percentage | 21 days (Classic/Deluxe; Accident Plan covers accidental injury only, so illness wait does not apply) | Not covered at all on the Accident Plan; 180 days on Classic/Deluxe | 6 weeks to 12 years (Accident); to 8 years 11 months (Classic/Deluxe, FAQ page) | No; paid to the policyholder's nominated NZ bank account | Not on Accident/Classic; free Dental Illness benefit on Deluxe only, $500 limit, 180-day wait | 5% for two or more pets (FAQ page) | PD NZ Pet Insurance Policy Wording |
 Petcover |
Provident Insurance Corporation Limited, FSP270065 (Petcover NZ Limited is the binding agent, FSP614229) | Nine plans in three families: Superior (Entry, Mid-Point, Superior), Mid-Range (Core, Vital, Key), Safety-net (Economy, Catastrophe 1, 2) | $5,000 (Mid-Range Core / Safety-net Catastrophe 1) | $0 / $100 / $200, Mid-Range only; the other families give a worked example in the PDS, not a published menu | 10% / 20% / 30%, Mid-Range only | 28 days (Mid-Range); 21 days (Superior, Economy); 30 days (Catastrophe) | 6 months, Mid-Range and Catastrophe only; no separately named extended wait in Superior or Economy beyond the standard illness wait | 8 weeks; 8th birthday cap for new business on Superior/Mid-Range; no published maximum for standard breeds on Economy | Opt-in "Pay Direct to Vet," needs the vet's agreement and Petcover's sign-off; Petcover reserves the right to decline | Accident dental only, conditional on annual dental checks; $50 teeth-cleaning benefit sits inside Mid-Range's optional "Day to Day Care" add-on | Threshold published (3+ eligible pets); the discount percentage itself is not published anywhere checked | Mid-Range PDS |
How the two insurers structure their plans
PD Insurance sells three named tiers, Accident, Classic and Deluxe, with a single set of dollar limits and sub-limits each (Policy Wording, retrieved 17 September 2026). Petcover sells nine named plans across three product families, and the mechanics differ by family: only Mid-Range (Core, Vital, Key) publishes a selectable $0 to $200 excess and a 10% to 30% co-payment menu; Superior and Economy describe the same Fixed Excess plus Optional Pet % Share Excess mechanism but leave the actual figures to an individualised Certificate of Insurance; and Catastrophe 1 and 2 publish only two fixed excess choices, $450 or $900, with a flat 100% reimbursement rate under age 8 (Superior PDS; Catastrophe PDS, both retrieved 17 September 2026). Working out what a claim actually costs on Petcover means first knowing which of the nine plans is on the certificate; on PD it means knowing which of the three tiers and which of the three excess options was chosen. See Pet insurance excess explained for how excess and co-payment interact generally.
Waiting periods and what counts as an accident
Both insurers carve cruciate ligament rupture and patella luxation out of the definition of an accident, which is what pushes those claims onto the longer illness-style wait rather than the immediate accident cover. PD's Policy Wording states: "Conditions that are not considered as accidental injury include luxating patella, Cruciate ligament rupture or strain, degenerative joint disease, hip/elbow dysplasia, hyperextending hocks" (Policy Wording, retrieved 17 September 2026), and as a result these conditions are not covered at all on PD's Accident Plan and carry a 180-day wait on Classic and Deluxe. Petcover's PDS uses near-identical wording: "the following Conditions are not considered Accidents: luxating patella; a rupture or strain of one or both cruciate ligaments; degenerative joint disease; hip dysplasia and hyperextending hocks" (Superior PDS, retrieved 17 September 2026), and Petcover's Mid-Range and Catastrophe PDS documents name an explicit 180-day Cruciate Ligament Disease wait, matching PD's figure, while Superior and Economy fall back to their standard illness wait with no separately named cruciate extension in the wording checked. See Pet insurance waiting periods and cruciate ligament surgery cost for what that surgery itself costs.
What happens to a chronic condition at renewal
This is the largest structural difference between the two insurers, and it sits in the small print rather than the plan tables. PD's Policy Wording defines an "Ongoing Condition" and caps it for the life of the policy at whatever dollar limit applied in the year it was first diagnosed: "the maximum amount we will pay during the pet's lifetime for the ongoing condition or for any related conditions, will be the benefit limit, claim limit or sub-limit that applied in the period of cover when the ongoing condition first presented... even if you continue to renew your pet's cover or upgrade your plan" (Policy Wording, retrieved 17 September 2026). Petcover's Superior, Mid-Range and Catastrophe plans instead use a defined term, "Umbrella for Life," meaning continuous cover for an ongoing illness or injury for the pet's lifetime provided the policy is renewed without a break (Superior PDS, retrieved 17 September 2026), though a lifetime-claims threshold of $36,000 (Superior) or $15,000 (Catastrophe) can trigger a specialist review or pre-authorisation requirement. Petcover's Economy plan is the exception: its Policy Benefits table states "Umbrella for Life: No," and cover for any injury or illness stops 12 months after it first arose, even with continuous renewal (Economy PDS, retrieved 17 September 2026). See lifetime vs annual pet insurance for how this distinction plays out across all seven NZ insurers, and pre-existing conditions for how each insurer treats a condition diagnosed before cover started.
Dental cover on the entry plans
Neither insurer's entry-level plan covers elective or disease-related dental work. On PD's Accident and Classic tiers, dental care is excluded outright except where damage results from a visible accidental injury; the Dental Illness benefit (abscesses, gingivitis, medically required tooth removal, $500 limit, 180-day wait) is bundled free into the Deluxe tier only and cannot be added to a lower tier (Policy Wording, retrieved 17 September 2026). Petcover's Mid-Range Core plan similarly excludes routine and disease dental work from core cover, but a $50-a-year teeth-cleaning contribution is available by adding the optional "Day to Day Care" benefit, shared with nine other wellness items a policyholder can pick one of (Mid-Range PDS, retrieved 17 September 2026). This add-on does not exist on Petcover's Superior, Economy or Catastrophe plans in the documents checked.
Questions people ask
Does PD Insurance or Petcover pay the vet directly?
Neither does so as standard. PD is reimbursement-only, paid to the policyholder's nominated NZ bank account, and explicitly states it does not contract vets on the policyholder's behalf (Policy Wording, retrieved 17 September 2026). Petcover offers an opt-in "Pay Direct to Vet" option, but it requires the vet to agree in advance and Petcover reserves the right to decline the request (Make a Claim page, retrieved 17 September 2026). See pet insurance that pays the vet directly for the insurers that do offer this as standard.
Which one has the lower excess?
PD's entry-level excess choices are $100, $150 or $200 per claim, with no separate co-payment percentage. Petcover's Mid-Range Core plan is the only one of its nine plans to publish a $0 excess option, but a 10% to 30% co-payment still applies on top of it (FAQ page; Mid-Range PDS, both retrieved 17 September 2026). Whether that is cheaper on any given claim depends on the claim size.
Do either cover cruciate ligament surgery straight away?
No. Both insurers exclude cruciate ligament rupture and patella luxation from their definition of an accident, so both apply an extended wait: 180 days on PD's Classic and Deluxe tiers (not covered at all on Accident), and 180 days on Petcover's Mid-Range and Catastrophe plans, with the standard illness wait applying on Superior and Economy in the absence of a separately named cruciate wait in those documents.
Is a multi-pet discount published for both?
Only PD publishes the percentage: 5% for two or more pets (FAQ page, retrieved 17 September 2026). Petcover's PDS documents confirm a multi-pet discount exists for three or more eligible pets but do not state the percentage anywhere checked.
A licensed NZ adviser can compare the pet insurers on your pet's details. Get pet cover quotes.
Adviser's view
QuoteHub's read is that PD Insurance's flat per-claim excess is simpler to budget against than Petcover's percentage co-payment, but Petcover's Superior and Mid-Range families carry a chronic condition forward for the life of the policy in a way PD's own wording, which freezes the dollar pool at the year a condition was first diagnosed, does not.
Get pet cover quotes from a licensed NZ adviser · free, no obligation.
Cite this page QuoteHub NZ (2026). PD Insurance vs Petcover: Wordings Compared. www.quotehub.co.nz/pet-insurance/pd-insurance-vs-petcover. Updated 2026-09-17.
Explore related pages: Life Insurance, Income Protection, Health Insurance, Trauma Insurance, Calculators.